Skip to content

The 11 Best WordPress Algolia Alternatives in 2023

Algolia‘s WordPress plugin was hugely popular for supercharging site search performance – but since they discontinued support in 2019, users have been seeking robust alternatives.

In this expert guide, we‘ll compare the top 11 Algolia alternatives for WordPress to help you find the best fit for empowering search on your site. Whether you need blazing speed, customizability or affordability, there’s a solution for you here.

We‘ll cover:

  • Brief Background on Why Algolia Alternatives Are Needed
  • Overview of Top 11 Algolia Alternatives for WordPress
  • Head-to-Head Comparison of Top 4 Alternatives
  • Tips for Selecting the Right Algolia Alternative
  • Step-by-Step Guide to Implementing Your Chosen Alternative
  • Extra Tips for Optimizing WordPress Site Search Performance

So let’s get started!

Why Are Algolia Alternatives Needed for WordPress?

First, some background. Algolia was a popular SaaS platform offering hosted search as a service. Their WordPress plugin supercharged the default WordPress search with enhanced speed, accuracy and relevance.

But in 2019, Algolia discontinued their WordPress plugin. This left many sites needing to migrate to an alternative search solution.

Here are some key reasons Algolia alternatives are popular:

  • Speed – The default WordPress search isn‘t known for being fast or performing well at scale. Alternatives like ElasticSearch offer much faster indexing and query times.

  • Accuracy & Relevance – Default WP search relevancy isn‘t great. Algolia alternatives allow tuning results to user search behavior.

  • Capabilities – Options like typo tolerance, autocomplete, synonyms, facets etc. enhance the user experience.

  • Support – Hosted services mean the provider handles infrastructure & optimization for you.

Let‘s now explore the top WordPress Algolia alternatives available…

Overview of Top 11 Algolia Alternatives for WordPress

Here are the most popular and capable Algolia alternatives to consider for supercharging WordPress search:

1. ElasticPress

ElasticPress replaces the standard WP search by integrating the enterprise-grade Elasticsearch engine. Blazing speed with relevant, high performance search capabilities.

  • Pros – Very fast, scalable search for large databases. Lots of customization & features.
  • Cons – Can involve complex setup & management without official hosting option.

2. SearchWP

Fully-managed search as a service tailored specifically for WordPress sites. Very customizable with solid performance.

  • Pros – Simple setup & management. Lots of options & tunability. Affordable pricing.
  • Cons – Limited free version. Some complex capabilities require developer skills.

3. Ajax Search Pro

Popular paid plugin with one-time pricing & lifetime updates. Very customizable search UIs minus some advanced features.

  • Pros – Budget-friendly pricing model. Easy to set up & use. Lots of search UI options.
  • Cons – Can impact site performance. Limited capabilities vs. other enterprise options.

4. Heroic Search

Free plugin building on WordPress’ native search capabilities. Lightweight option improving existing search relevancy.

  • Pros – Free & easy setup directly through WordPress. Better default search relevancy.
  • Cons – Fairly basic features. Limited customization capabilities.

5. Jetpack Search

Search plugin bundled with Jetpack‘s WordPress enhancements. Focuses on relevance over speed or customization.

  • Pros – Free for Jetpack users. Decent basic capabilities. Tight WP integration.
  • Cons – Slow indexing. Limited options to tune search performance.

6. SearchWP Live

"Search as a service" cloud subscription to handle everything from infrastructure to relevancy tuning.

  • Pros – Fully managed solution to optimize search without DevOps. Custom plugins & widgets.
  • Cons – Premium pricing model. Potential lock-in vs. self-hosted open search.

7. Typesense

Open-source, fast search engine like Algolia. Developer-oriented but with WordPress plugin available.

  • Pros – Open source search engine. Developer friendly. Customization options.
  • Cons – Requires self hosting & expertise to implement, manage & scale.

8. AWS CloudSearch

Managed search engine by Amazon Web Services. Enterprise-scale capabilities fully handled.

  • Pros – Robust infrastructure, scaling & redundancy from AWS.
  • Cons – Complex setup. Premium pricing based on traffic & resources used.

9. Swiftype

Powerful SaaS search from Elastic. Tailored relevance with managed infrastructure.

  • Pros – Strong capabilities. Tuned relevancy algorithms. Handles scaling.
  • Cons – Setup can get complex for larger deployments. One of the pricier options.

10. AddSearch

Premium plugin for advanced search capabilities, spiders all site content with updates.

  • Pros – Powerful search features out of the box. Good customization options.
  • Cons – Expensive subscription pricing. Potential performance impacts.

11. Search & Filter

Another advanced premium plugin alternative. Focus is filtering & search UI flexibility.

  • Pros – Multiple search UIs. Lots of filtering & drilling options.
  • Cons – Very expensive. Mostly just search presentation capabilities.

This covers a broad selection of self-hosted open source options, commercial plugins and fully managed "search as a service" solutions.

Now let‘s compare some of the most popular Algolia alternative options head-to-head across key criteria…

Head-to-Head Comparison of Top Algolia Alternatives

To help narrow down your options, here‘s a direct head-to-head comparison of 4 leading Algolia alternatives for WordPress:

  • ElasticPress
  • SearchWP
  • Ajax Search Pro
  • Jetpack Search

Let‘s stack them up across five key decision criteria:

1. Speed & Performance

  • ElasticPress – Uses Elasticsearch for best performance overall. Ultra fast indexing & query response times.
  • SearchWP – Hosted option built for speed. Indexing can lag but queries are snappy.
  • Ajax Search – AJAX search suffers slower indexing & query times vs. alternatives.
  • Jetpack – Slowest indexing makes this a poor performer. OK query speeds.

Winner – ElasticPress

2. Capabilities & Features

  • ElasticPress – Extremely robust advanced capabilities given Elasticsearch foundation.
  • SearchWP – Very feature rich options. Lots of native integrations & customizability.
  • Ajax Search – Good standard + advanced plugin features. Decent customization options.
  • Jetpack – Fairly limited. Lagging roadmap for search-specific capabilities.

Winner – Tie – ElasticPress and SearchWP

3. Customization & Tuning

  • ElasticPress – Very customizable but requires technical expertise.
  • SearchWP – Intuitive dashboard to tweak settings. Good developer options too.
  • Ajax Search – Tons of UI customization flexibility out of the box.
  • Jetpack – Very limited customization or tuning possible.

Winner – Ajax Search Pro

4. Support & Maintenance

  • ElasticPress – Some documentation but limited support. Tuning is do-it-yourself.
  • SearchWP – Excellent onboarding & support. Handling by provider.
  • Ajax Search – Decent support forums & docs. Updates through WordPress.org.
  • Jetpack – Standard WordPress.org forums & support options.

Winner – SearchWP

5. Pricing & Value

  • ElasticPress – Open core free. Extended options & hosting packages extra cost.
  • SearchWP – Very reasonably priced subscriptions with good value.
  • Ajax Search – One-time competitive pricing. Great budget choice.
  • Jetpack – Free for Jetpack users. Extra resources incur added fees.

Winner – Ajax Search Pro

Conclusion

  • ElasticPress dominates speed while matching SearchWP on capabilities. Better for technical users.
  • SearchWP nearly keeps pace feature-wise. Managed service trades some speed for convenience.
  • Ajax Search excels for easy customization on a budget.
  • Jetpack ranks last across the board except for its free pricing for Jetpack users.

This analysis shows ElasticPress as the power user option while SearchWP offers the best blend of performance, features and managed convenience. Ajax Search is best for easy UI customization on a budget.

Now let’s wrap up with some tips for selecting the right Algolia alternative…

Tips for Selecting the Right WordPress Algolia Alternative

Here are key tips for choosing your Algolia alternative:

Consider Your Technical Proficiency

Managed services like SearchWP handle the complexity for you. Self-hosted open source options like ElasticPress offer maximum control for technical users.

Factor in Site Traffic & Scale

All options can work for small sites. For high traffic at scale, ElasticPress and cloud hosted choices fare best.

Audit Search Usage & Behavior

Review Google Analytics to understand key search terms, trends and conversions to inform your choice.

Compare Features vs. Plugins

Many standard features come built-in or through plugins. Factor in their availability for any option.

Choose Tuning Support Level

Some services like SearchWP handle all tuning. Others like ElasticPress leave optimization up to you.

Evaluate Budget Tradeoffs

Free and freemium models have limits. Paid plans bring more capabilities and support.

Getting the above criteria aligned with your priorities will ensure you land on the right WordPress Algolia alternative!

Let‘s now walk through the implementation process…

Step-by-Step Guide to Implementing Your Chosen Alternative

While each Algolia alternative for WordPress may differ somewhat, the general implementation process follows this sequence:

Step 1: Install WordPress Plugin

All options have an associated plugin to provide integration. Install this directly within your WordPress admin.

Step 2: Activate License or Sign Up

For paid and managed services, you’ll need to activate a valid license key or sign up for an account.

Step 3: Configure Settings

Most plugins include various settings to specify indexing approach, search UI and other defaults.

Step 4: Customize Design Treatment

Tweak search form placement, styling as needed to match your theme design & UX.

Step 5: Test Search Performance

Validate indexing status and test out sample queries to gauge performance. Tune if needed.

Step 6: Analyze Usage Data

Plugins with search analytics help you identify issues and fine tune both results and UI.

And that’s it! Follow those steps to get your chosen WordPress Algolia alternative successfully integrated.

Now for some final tips…

Extra Tips for Optimizing WordPress Search Performance

Whichever alternative you choose, here are bonus tips for making sure your WordPress search performance shines:

  • Choose a caching plugin – Caching reduces database load dramatically so searches are snappier.

  • Enable CDN distribution – Distribute static assets globally so search pages load faster.

  • Implement selective indexing – Avoid indexing unnecessary content like images or duplicate posts.

  • Tune for relevance – Use search analytics to understand behaviors and tweak result accuracy.

  • Set up 301 redirects – Redirect outdated search result links to current equivalents.

  • Add auto-complete – Fasterindications of result potential improve user experience.

So there you have it – everything you need to know to find the right WordPress Algolia alternative for your site and implement it for superior search performance.

The key is matching the feature set to your level of technical proficiency while aligning with your budget and priorities.

Hopefully the insights and recommendations provided here will help you zero in on the perfect option!

Let us know if you have any other questions. Happy searching!

Tags: